Bob Barnard Track Engineering

For the largest motor racing organisation in the US NASCAR remains in the dark ages in some respects. Manual jacks with a guy running around carrying it. 5 stud wheels and big men carrying cans of fuel. We saw last night at Richmond what the inevitable consequence of that last item is, an inferno as the nozzle malfunctioned and fuel ignited, probably on the hot rotor of the rear wheel while the wheel was being changed. I feel for the three injured guys, especially the wheel changer, he must have been inside it. Why have the fuel cap over the rear wheel anyway? 

It does not take a malfunction for this to hapen though. We see at every pit stop fuel sloshing around as the can is withdrawn. What major race series in the world still fills cars from fuel cans? Even Indycar with what I would expect are far less budgets can afford dry break fuel rigs. We are no longer looking at good old boys in their stock cars, this is a highly professional sport run in the main by highly technically competent teams. So why do we still do this type of thing? Culture I expect, like the bumps around Sebring. As I have said before, if we did not change we would still be racing Roman Chariots. But then there would be no risk of fire. 

I commend the fire marshals, on the spot, fast reactions and had the fire out quickly. Well done, and brave too with open face helmets! Again, why would you ask someone to go to that conflagration with his face exposed? 

So NASCAR has "reacted quickly" to the death of Kevin Ward Jr. and made a new rule for drivers to stay in their car unless in dire emergency. Not so quickly as some local oval series, but they have reacted.

That is the point. They react to an incident and stick a band aid on it. How about being pro-active? Blind Freddy could see that sooner or later a driver wandering around on a hot race track seeking payback was going to be hit. It took a death to fix it. But what if Tony Stewart had not been the driver to hit Kevin? Suppose it was just another Saturday night local racer? Would we even have heard about it? We kill or maim people every week on tracks in the US, and unless someone well known is involved who cares? Ray Dunlap said on NASCAR Race Hub in the week that 25 people are killed a year, and I bet that is just in the NASCAR related races he knows about. What about kart tracks, private testing, track days etc?

I saw the reaction of one track after a 12 year old boy on a kart was decapitated for the lack of a barrier. They immediately installed a fence, straw bales, tires and plastic barriers. They said they could not do it beforehand as they could not predict where the accident would happen! There are tracks built all around the world where the basis of their design is the prediction of accidents and measures put in place to prevent or ameliorate them. We have over 100 years of knowledge and experience and now computer simulation to assist us, so why do we still have tracks that do not install the basic systems or do so incorrectly?

It took a big wreck at Watkins Glen for drivers to ask for improvements. Let's see how fast NASCAR reacts to that.

Let me say at the outset that I am extremely sorry for the family of Kevin Ward Jr. No one deserves to die doing what they love, especially in these circumstances. However, I have on numerous occasions have had cause to remind drivers who are out of their cars at the scene of a crash that they are not immortal. They have just crashed there and so can someone else. Get over the barrier. It is unfortunate that it is part of the NASCAR and Sprint Car culture to wait and find the 'culprit" and wag the finger or throw something, all with cars going past, albeit at non-race speed. As we have seen they do not need to be going at race speed to inflict mortal injuries. This has to stop.

As with most of the expert witness cases I handle the only person who really knows what happened is no longer alive to tell the story. Only Kevin really knows what he did, I am sure Tony was not expecting it. What is remarkable is the Sheriff's involvement. I can only recall one case where the police attended, rare in itself, and conducted an investigation. Usually they decide this is a private facility and leave. On one case they did detail the fight that followed the accident and injury, but not the accident!

So why this case? Is Tony really seen to be a driver likely to run over someone on purpose? No way, he may be tough, but he lives for racing, and I for one cannot believe it. From the video I have seen it looks as if the rear wheels move away from Kevin, not toward. If it were Jimmy Johnson, Jeff Gordon, or Jr. would the police really be looking at this?

So Tony does not drive at Watkins Glen, and rightly so. We saw some great racing, especially my Aussie mate Ambrose showing them how to really drive. Some hard racing but clean. Well done AJ, fought for and deserved that first win. I still find it hard to perceive that oval racing is so different that guys like Ambrose and Montoya cannot translate their obvious world class talent into oval wins, but it obviously is.

What was graphically demonstrated was how in need of an full course update Watkins Glen is. I have offered to go up and provide a report but of course NASCAR knows better. That is why we still use sand barrels and tire walls built totally wrong. Several drivers offered the same comment but then said it would cost too much. Watkins Glen is owned by the largest track owner in the world, ISC, and they cannot afford it? I loved Alan Bestwick's comment that the track narrows near the site of the big crash due to a "natural feature," meaning the tunnel. What, it was there before they built the track? Just one of the many ill-informed comments. This layout is great, it just needs bringing up to modern standards, and yes you can accommodate different users and configurations. Even the guard rail is still acceptable, it did not fail and was a softer hit than a concrete wall. Just a pain to repair. It is just in the wrong place on most of the track.

Marquez won his tenth straight MotoGP at Indy, but who was there to see it. Red Bull must be paying for all this as the crowd certainly isn't. Same story with the Tudor Sports car race which thankfully is not to return. MotoGP needs to go to tracks that show off their product, not just somewhere that pays the most. 

A big weekend of racing. MotoGP turned on their usual good show, but Turn 1 at COTA? Tilke missed a great opportunity to make that a really good corner. Instead we have a crash site. But the commentators were at it again. "The most competitive field we have ever seen." Seriously? Where were you in the late 80's and early nineties when Gardner, Doohan, Magee, Rainey, Lawson, Mamola, Koscinski, Sarron, Schwantz and co. were around?

Indycar at Long Beach had its usual accidents at the usual locations. How anyone thinks this can be an F1 track is beyond me. If they left out some of the petunias around the base of the fountain we might have a track wide enough to race on. The Tudor Sports car race was a yawn. Time was when an LMP2 car could beat an LMP1 car around here, but now it cannot even beat a DP.

There is always the quote that "it's a long race" by drivers, even if it is the same length as all the rest, but Saturday evening we really did have a long race. 500 miles around Darlington took forever. I wondered why it started so early. It was all I could do to stay awake.

Which brings me to the point. I come from a European back ground with a spell in Oz, so I am used to watching a sport event without it being turned into a continuous commercial. Sky manages to show an entire F1 race without ads, so why can't Fox or NBC? I know Sky is subscription, but all the sport here in the US is basically on cable which I pay for anyway. NASCAR is by far the worst, a race being one long ad, even when the race is being shown with every opportunity taken to show a sponsor logo for Kentucky Fried, Sprint, Progressive Insurance etc. Then there are the "infomercials" during the sports car races, and Indycar has to go off and interview anyone they can find that they think is a star of anything. 

There has to be a template for showing sport in this country that includes three old farts in suits and ties blabbing on, and usually a female studio anchor and pit lane or side line reporter. With an average age of probably sixty the boys on NBC for F1 have about as much chance of bringing in a younger fan than I have of being knighted. Take a look at the Sky guys. They are at a race track and dressed like you would expect at a race. NASCAR and Indycar and even the NFL are all the same. Is this just me or is it that the TV guys know what the average American sports fan wants. A blonde bimbo with big tits.

Now that's off my chest, so to speak, let's look at F1 goings on. Domenicali has fallen on his sword, or was he pushed, and his obvious replacement is a car salesman. First guy I would have picked, not. Perhaps Montezemolo is actually the problem. Bernie's problems are about to get worse with the prosecution dismissing his blackmail defense. But the judge is going to give him days off it seems to run F1. Red Bull lost the appeal, as they should. Whining that they could not keep second place if they obeyed the rules is a strange defence. There are probably twenty other cars out there who feel they could win if allowed to cheat a bit. Or is that just me?

Bernie has just worked out what Renault engineers said two weeks ago and anyone with a mechanical bent knew anyway. When you have turbocharged engines it is hard to nigh impossible to increase the noise level. Noise is generated by the exhaust gas pushing the air which eventually beats against your ear drum. Turbos use that energy. That is why most earthmoving equipment do not require a muffler. The whole point of this formula is to use the waste energy, so what are we going to do? Waste some of what we just saved to give the whiners more noise? I guess we would not be able to hear them whine.

Bernie is also muddying the waters as usual, suggesting he could set up a "new" FI with GP2 cars, but call them GP1. Gets more noise, more teams and it would be cheaper. But hang on, didn't he just block a cost cap for the real F1? 

Teams stayed on in Bahrain to test some more, but information seems lost in transmission.

Watched the delayed NASCAR race from Texas yesterday. The end was good as usual, even if contrived by a yellow 3 laps from the flag. Kurt Bush had a close shave with the wall but did not touch it, and had a tire come apart on the apron. Enough for the guys at NASCAR, or did they lean on the button again? Bush spin earlier without hitting anything and continued and they threw the yellow then too. Lugano was not to be denied though and deservedly won from Gordon. We saw a lot of yellow, with the race starting under yellow for 12 laps as the track was still "damp." Rain tires anyone? I can understand them not running in the rain, the spray would be terrible, but a bit damp is no big deal.

Wet grass is another thing though as we saw with Junior's excursion. Tore his car up and Johnson's who was close behind. Jr. caught fire and thankfully got out OK as we saw an IMSA style chinese fire drill. While the boys on the fire truck were working out how to turn the hose on a marshal leant over the wall with a normal extinguisher and put it out. Not good enough.  We then had to have the "competition caution" of course as the track was "green" and the teams would not have known how to set the car up. It has rained every day from what I saw so what was different?

Missed the anniversary of Jim Clark's death yesterday. One of those "where were you when" moments. I was at Brands Hatch, where Clark was supposed to be, not racing an F2 race at Hockenheim. An incredible talent, and a humble gentlemen, not like our current World Champion. No one finger salute after races for Jim.